Verdict in Trial of Essex County Sheriff’s Officer Accused of Threatening Woman

A decision was handed down in the trial of the Essex County sheriff’s officer accused of threatening to kill a 22-year-old woman.

The jury ruled that 39-year-old John Warnock was not guilty on three charges; however, the case is not yet resolved because the jury hung on one charge and found Warnock guilty on another charge.

Warnock reportedly picked up the victim at a West Orange bar in 2012. While driving the woman home, Warnock allegedly threatened to kill her.

According to prosecutors, proof of the verbal assault came from another woman who heard Warnock tell the victim, “Take your panties down or I’ll kill you.” The acting assistant prosecutor in the case said that Warnock accidentally made a call on his cell phone during the drive home. Since the phone was in Warnock’s pocket, he did not realize it was turned on.

Prosecutors also said that Warnock called the victim a “batty bitch” while she was inside his truck. The harassment charge stemmed from that alleged comment.

The victim, in fear for her life, reportedly escaped by jumping from the truck while it was still moving in Nutley.

Warnock was eventually arrested and charged with a number of criminal offenses. His case was transferred from Essex County to Hudson County because of his status as an Essex County’s sheriff’s officer.

At the conclusion of the trial in Hudson County Superior Court, Warnock listened to the jury forewoman as she read the verdict.

On the charges of criminal restraint, terroristic threats, and official misconduct, the jury found Warnock not guilty. Meanwhile, the jury hung on the charge of criminal coercion and ruled that Warnock was guilty of the lesser charge of harassment.

Due to the hung jury, Warnock will have to wait until later this year for the case to be resolved as the prosecution decides whether to seek a re-trial on the criminal coercion charge.

For more information about this case, view the article entitled “Essex County Sheriff’s Officer Not Guilty of Three Counts; Mixed Verdicts on Other Charges.”

NJ Attorney General Clarifies Sentencing Requirements in Gun Possession Cases
South Orange Police Look for Suspects in Gas Station Robbery
Client Reviews
testimonials reviews
  • "Travis Tormey is the only lawyer I seek out to handle my legal affairs. Over the last four years, I have used Mr. Tormey’s services on numerous occasions to my great benefit. He promptly returns my messages, takes the time..."

  • "Travis Tormey is a superb attorney. He is skilled and knowledgeable. He handled my case with respect, kindness and quiet assurance. I would trust him with all future legal needs. He has many contacts in the legal profession..."

  • "Mr. Tormey is a consummate professional. Our case was sensitive and complicated and unusually lengthy for a juvenile case. For 8 months Mr. Tormey faithfully worked our case and never failed to show for court once. Punctual, disciplined..."

  • "Travis Tormey is an outstanding attorney. He helped me tremendously, more so than I ever could have imagined. He handled all aspects of my case with compassion, respect, and immense competence. He is a skilled and knowledge..."

  • "I was extremely nervous and anticipating the worst situation possible for my cases. Travis was a very reliable lawyer and everyone at his firm was extremely helpful. Travis went above and beyond inside and outside of the court room for me! ..."

Our Offices

Hackensack Law Office

254 State Street Hackensack, NJ 07601

Get Directions Hackensack Law Office

Newark Law Office

1 Gateway Center, Suite 2600 Newark, NJ 07102

Get Directions Newark Law Office